clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile
Overhead view of a table full of seafood dishes, including a platter of oysters, a basket of fried clams and fries, rare bluefin tuna, and more
A spread of food at the Banks Fish House in Boston’s Back Bay.
Rachel Leah Blumenthal/Eater

Filed under:

From Fried Seafood to Luxurious Shellfish Towers, the Banks Fish House Has Arrived

The sibling to upscale steakhouse Grill 23 is now open in Boston’s Back Bay

There’s a new seafood restaurant in town: The Banks Fish House, located in the former Post 390 space at 406 Stuart St. in Boston’s Back Bay, opened on July 21, sibling restaurant to Grill 23, Bistro du Midi, and Harvest. Owner Chris Himmel and executive chef and partner Robert Sisca are drawing on their fishing adventures around the globe, as well as Sisca’s experiences as a chef throughout the northeast and the seafood purveyor friends he’s made along the way, to fill the two-story space with everything from casual fried seafood dishes to loaded towers of shellfish and caviar.

Sisca’s years in Rhode Island, for example, inspired a Point Judith calamari dish, served with pickled peppers, jalapenos, and a blue claw crab ragu based on a sauce his mother made while he was growing up. From Sisca’s time in Boston, there are fried artichokes, which used to be a fan favorite on the Bistro du Midi menu, served here with an Old Bay aioli.

Here’s an inside look at some of the dishes on the opening menu:


Overhead view of a silver platter of oysters on the half shell, served with half a lemon, a mignonette, a tiny bottle of hot sauce, and other accompaniments.
Oysters and accoutrements, including a tin of the Banks Fish House’s own caviar.

The Banks is a New England fish house; of course there are oysters. The rotating selection will always include Island Creek oysters from Duxbury, Massachusetts; something from Maine, such as Snow Island or Mookie Blue oysters; a couple West Coast options; and more. Watch for one of Sisca’s local favorites, South Bay Blondes from Onset, Massachusetts.

The Banks also has has a dish of Taunton Bay oysters from Maine. “Since Maine plays such a big part in oysters, I wanted to put a composed Maine oyster dish on,” says Sisca. It includes Maine uni as well as a relish made with Sweet Reaper hot sauce from Martha’s Vineyard, which is made by O Ya alum Nathan Gould. (Gould’s smoked bluefish pate also makes an appearance on the menu.)

The Banks’s raw oysters are pictured here with a tin of the restaurant’s own osetra caviar, sourced via Regiis Ova; there’s also Island Creek white sturgeon caviar and Black River imperial osetra from Uruguay. Diners can add caviar to anything or order it on its own with creme fraiche, blini, and hash browns. It’s also in the fanciest of the restaurant’s three seafood towers, accompanying enough shellfish, lobster, and crudo to feed six to eight people.

“The Chowda” Flatbread

An oval flatbread with a slightly charred crust is topped with oyster crackers, sliced potatoes, and bits of bacon. It sits on a wooden board on a brown leather booth, with a blue and white striped booth back visible in the background.
“The Chowda” flatbread at the Banks Fish House.

Sisca and Himmel intend for the Banks to be the type of place where you can grab a casual cup of chowder and glass of rosé at the bar or come in for a caviar-drenched shellfish feast, or anything in between. In addition to the actual chowder, which is made with pork belly and served with a dinner roll, there’s a chowder flatbread. Sisca is “really excited” about this dish, which is a play on pizza vongole, clam pizza, “kind of a classic pizza in Italian restaurants.” The chowder flatbread has a creme fraiche base, bacon, clams, and potatoes, and it’s topped with oyster crackers “to give it texture and kind of bring the chowder together.”

There’s also a simple margherita flatbread as well as a cioppino (prawns, squid, mussels, Gruyere). For the cioppino, Sisca takes some of the broth for the Banks’s lobster bake and reduces it down with tomato sauce.

Fried Seafood

Fried clams, fries, a lemon wedge, and a silver cup of remoulade sit on newspaper in a black basket. A white and black tiled floor is visible underneath.
Fried whole belly clams and fries at the Banks Fish House.

The fried whole belly clam dish, pictured above, is one of several fried seafood dishes at the Banks; it’s served with fries and lemon tarragon remoulade. There’s also a fried fishermen’s platter with haddock, shrimp, and scallops, each prepared in a different batter and fried at a different temperature in a different basket “to make it perfect,” says Sisca. The platter comes with a “sea chi” remoulade, made with kelp-based kimchi from Atlantic Sea Farms in Maine.

Bread Crusted Halibut

A thick piece of halibut topped with a crispy breading sits in a yellow pool of sauce with asparagus, tomatoes, small round pasta bits, and mussels.
Bread crusted halibut at the Banks Fish House.

“It’s a technique I learned years ago,” says Sisca, where sourdough bread is frozen and sliced paper-thin on a meat slicer and the fish bakes in the oven on top of a slice of bread. “It’s almost cooked three different ways: It steams, it roasts, it bakes.” Sisca flips it over after baking, resulting in a crispy breading and moist fish. The halibut is accompanied by Prince Edward Island mussels, a nod to Sisca and Himmel’s bluefin tuna fishing trips there. “As you drive through, you see all the mussel beds everywhere,” says Sisca. Asparagus, fregola sarda, and a yellow tomato broth round out the dish.

Grilled Bluefin Tuna Steak

Four slices of rare tuna sit on a bed of roasted eggplant and green olives on a white plate. Crispy artichokes and fresh herbs garnish the plate.
Grilled bluefin tuna steak at the Banks Fish House.

Another nod to the PEI fishing trips, the grilled bluefin tuna steak — served rare or however you want — comes with grilled artichokes and “almost a ratatouille or caponata” of roasted eggplants, onions, garlic, tomatoes, and green olives.

The tuna steak and halibut join a handful of other seafood entrees on the menu, including a Dover sole meuniere, cuttlefish spaghetti, and — a favorite of Sisca’s kids — crispy fish tacos.

But there are a few options for non-seafood eaters, too, including sibling restaurant Grill 23’s 100-day Brandt rib-eye, a Giannone half chicken, or filet mignon. (Add a steamed lobster tail to any of them.)

The Banks Fish House is currently open for dinner Tuesday through Saturday and lunch Tuesday through Friday, with brunch coming soon. There’s seating on both floors — including several private dining areas — and the large space includes several fireplaces, a raw bar, two bars, an open kitchen, and Back Bay views. Reserve a table online to get a taste of the culmination of Sisca and Himmel’s years as fishermen.

“There are so many friends I’ve made over the years cooking seafood for this long,” says Sisca. “It just really goes from them to me to the plate.”

The Banks Fish House

406 Stuart Street, , MA 02116 (617) 399-0015 Visit Website
Eater Awards

Here Are 2023’s Eater Award Winners for Boston

Boston Restaurant Openings

New York City’s Blue Ribbon Brasserie Makes Its Boston Debut

Boston Restaurant Openings

A Sought-After Sichuan Restaurant Arrives in Boston